Well, I do want a fine Christian gentleman who has saved himself for the right person

That's for sure. In my book: the less experienced, the better.
I do not know for sure what you mean by attractive. But let's just say I do care about looks. I do not want or need a GQ model- just someone who is at least decent looking and takes good care of himself.
I'm not a religious fanatic either. I do have a healthy attitude towards human sexuality and believe that it is for the union of two persons who love each other, not just for reproduction. But I do have Christian morals.
Told you I was a square peg in a round hole!